First post! Mwa hahahahaha… aww. That’s far less satisfying when you’re the only one allowed to post.
If you haven’t seen Joss Whedon’s musical masterpiece Dr. Horrible’s Sing Along Blog, well, where the hell have you been the last week? Your geek cred is now in negative digits. I don’t care how many conventions you’ve dressed up as Spike or Malcolm Reynolds or Sailor Moon, you get an F. Seriously, go watch it, it’s a musical online series made up of three, 15 minute acts. Watching the whole thing will take less than an hour, you can get it on iTunes. If you’re not a fan of digital shackles, I’m sure it’s on bittorrent by now. It won’t hurt, I promise.
You watch it yet? Good. Ok, so I lied, it did hurt a bit at the end. Suck it up, you wussy. And for all of you who haven’t seen it yet, stop reading right now. I wouldn’t want to spoil anything for you (not so subtle hint, but I know some people need it spelled out, so: SPOILERS AHEAD).
Since everyone under the bloody sun has commented on this, I’m going to fill the gap by addressing what hasn’t been mentioned. The two comments I hear in some corners has to do with lack of character development and issues with Penny’s character.
To everyone complaining about the lack of character development of Penny or Captain Hammer, you’re missing the fucking point. Captain Hammer is a caricature and is supposed to be a shallow, self centered jerk that our villain (hero?) can fight against. Unless you think having super strength or a freeze ray that can stop time is realistic?
The other complaint I’ve heard has to do with the stereotypical weak female character, portrayed by Penny, played by the gorgeous Queen of the Geeks, Felicia Day. Penny fills the role that so many women have played in TV, movies and comic books, which is that of the saintly female who is fought over by other males, but largely does nothing but look pretty and be a good influence on the menfolk. To a certain extent, I understand and sympathize with this complaint. It would have been cool if Penny turned out to be an arch villain or sabotaged Captain Hammer or even figured out who Billy Buddy was before the dramatic final moment. But then it would have been a different story, wouldn’t it?
When you’re limiting a story to three chunks of 15 minutes, you have to make compromises, ask what’s really important to the story, to the metaphor being displayed. In this case, Penny embodies Dr. Horrible’s idea of the status quo, of the sheep he’s trying to herd and cull. The fact he falls in love with her is profound and paradoxical. Could Penny have been smarter, seen through his alter ego and ruled beside him? Sure, but not only would the story have changed dramatically, there would be less significance to her death at the end. The thing I love most about the series is how things escalate from harmless heists to murder and death. In the last 5 minutes, things go from comic to tragic in a heartbeat, resulting in a seriously unhinged super baddy. The only other series I’ve seen that can go from comic to tragic that quickly and masterfully is the TV show Titus, which aired on Fox from 2000-2003.
I have plenty more to say about Dr. Horrible’s Sing Along Blog, but most of it has been said already, and by people more talented than me. One thing I can say is watching this for the fourth time over the weekend made me brush off the notes I had on a San Francisco based Spaced analogue and made me work on it some more. Only now, I really want to do it as 15 minute online episodes instead of the traditional network pitch. Well played, Whedon, well played.
Dr. Horrible’s Sing Along Blog
Monday, July 21st, 2008First post! Mwa hahahahaha… aww. That’s far less satisfying when you’re the only one allowed to post.
If you haven’t seen Joss Whedon’s musical masterpiece Dr. Horrible’s Sing Along Blog, well, where the hell have you been the last week? Your geek cred is now in negative digits. I don’t care how many conventions you’ve dressed up as Spike or Malcolm Reynolds or Sailor Moon, you get an F. Seriously, go watch it, it’s a musical online series made up of three, 15 minute acts. Watching the whole thing will take less than an hour, you can get it on iTunes. If you’re not a fan of digital shackles, I’m sure it’s on bittorrent by now. It won’t hurt, I promise.
You watch it yet? Good. Ok, so I lied, it did hurt a bit at the end. Suck it up, you wussy. And for all of you who haven’t seen it yet, stop reading right now. I wouldn’t want to spoil anything for you (not so subtle hint, but I know some people need it spelled out, so: SPOILERS AHEAD).
Since everyone under the bloody sun has commented on this, I’m going to fill the gap by addressing what hasn’t been mentioned. The two comments I hear in some corners has to do with lack of character development and issues with Penny’s character.
To everyone complaining about the lack of character development of Penny or Captain Hammer, you’re missing the fucking point. Captain Hammer is a caricature and is supposed to be a shallow, self centered jerk that our villain (hero?) can fight against. Unless you think having super strength or a freeze ray that can stop time is realistic?
The other complaint I’ve heard has to do with the stereotypical weak female character, portrayed by Penny, played by the gorgeous Queen of the Geeks, Felicia Day. Penny fills the role that so many women have played in TV, movies and comic books, which is that of the saintly female who is fought over by other males, but largely does nothing but look pretty and be a good influence on the menfolk. To a certain extent, I understand and sympathize with this complaint. It would have been cool if Penny turned out to be an arch villain or sabotaged Captain Hammer or even figured out who Billy Buddy was before the dramatic final moment. But then it would have been a different story, wouldn’t it?
When you’re limiting a story to three chunks of 15 minutes, you have to make compromises, ask what’s really important to the story, to the metaphor being displayed. In this case, Penny embodies Dr. Horrible’s idea of the status quo, of the sheep he’s trying to herd and cull. The fact he falls in love with her is profound and paradoxical. Could Penny have been smarter, seen through his alter ego and ruled beside him? Sure, but not only would the story have changed dramatically, there would be less significance to her death at the end. The thing I love most about the series is how things escalate from harmless heists to murder and death. In the last 5 minutes, things go from comic to tragic in a heartbeat, resulting in a seriously unhinged super baddy. The only other series I’ve seen that can go from comic to tragic that quickly and masterfully is the TV show Titus, which aired on Fox from 2000-2003.
I have plenty more to say about Dr. Horrible’s Sing Along Blog, but most of it has been said already, and by people more talented than me. One thing I can say is watching this for the fourth time over the weekend made me brush off the notes I had on a San Francisco based Spaced analogue and made me work on it some more. Only now, I really want to do it as 15 minute online episodes instead of the traditional network pitch. Well played, Whedon, well played.
Posted in Dr Horrible, Joss Whedon, TV, commentary | 2 Comments »